Open Letter to Mr. Mukesh Ambani

Dear Mr. Mukesh Ambani,

Wish you are well. Ignoring letter writing skills acquired in school, I am going to start with recollection of personal incident instead of the intent or subject of this letter.

Almost 10 years ago or so, while strolling on the streets of Shrinathji and munching on 'Ratalu', my father proudly mentioned to me, while pointing at a construction site, "Son, this is the site of upcoming Dhiraj Dham. Its being build by the Ambani's who are also devout Vaishnavs like us." At that point I couldn't tell, whether he was more proud of the fact that we are generational Reliance investors or that you share religious beliefs with us. I was in college those days and had little knowledge or interest in shares/stock market. BUT I certainly felt a deep sense of pride that we both were 'practicing' Vaishnavs who frequented Shrinathji annually if not more.

Here is a recent story from the kingdom of Ravana.

A Buddhist monk has suffered serious injuries after setting himself on fire to protest against the slaughter of cattle.
Sri Lankan police said the monk set himself on fire today near the famed Temple of Buddha's Tooth Relic in the central town of Kandy.

You might wonder what does a monk setting himself on fire [to save cattle] has to do with me? Be patient, the answer has to [or so I hope] come from with in.

I can skip another meeting and write more stories, But with the sad reality of corporate structures that exist today, I do not want to undertake the risk of my letter being trashed by your subordinate before it makes it to your table.[Knocking on wood] I do understand your time is valuable. So much that you alone are capable of fighting India's sanitation problem single handedly with your ever increasing net worth.

If you have made it this far, chances are that I have your marginal attention since a multi-tasking billionaire tycoon would look imbecile paying utmost attention to a small letter by roadside investor.

Kindly spend just spend 12 minutes along with Mrs. Ambani

[who is very spirited and spiritual individual based public information]

to watch the video below.



Done watching? At this point you must do two things. First, acknowledge either by writing back to me or in your heart that you have understood what this letter is about. Second, you must thank Shrji bava that fortunately your father did not stick around to learn that you have decided to enter 'the flesh business'. Yes, he sure was a shrewd businessman and would be enthralled to see your business empire grow, but IMHO, certainly not with blood on your hands. You have become victim of West's flawed business philosophy that personal beliefs/religion and business do not go together/be kept separate etc etc. The counter argument to that is one must remain "dharmic" at all places at all times, just as one must breath at all places at all times.

Ever heard of BeVegCanada Campaign? Living in US, on one side, it is ironic to watch so many spirited ordinary Hindus and Christians alike working tirelessly to promote vegetarian diets and reduce meat consumption and in turn cruelty towards voiceless/helpless animals where as on the other side people like you, listed on Forbes world's most powerful individual's list, with immense power and "paisa" overrun the very faith they are born in to. You bring tears of pain in fellow Vaishnav's eyes. Please do not take this as curse/complaint/rant. This is just a hopeless attempt by an ordinary Vaishnav to guide another Vaishnav's conscience which lost direction on Mumbai's Dalal Street. I am no Sanjay of Mahabharat with supernatural ability to foresee future. So I cannot predict how, when or why but rest assured, if you are entering 'the flesh business' with millions of devout Vaishnavs/Jains/Hindus hard-earned money [and trust], it's all downhill for you, your family and RIL from this point onwards.

P.S. As a third generation small time Gujarati investor, I am selling all my RIL stocks and will request every Gujarati that I know of to do the same. I will also write to the Nathdwara temple board administration urging them to de-list "Dhiraj Dham" from their website and severe ties with you and your family.

Massacre on ManGadh Hills/ માનગઢ હત્યા-કાંડ

Disclaimer: Sincere efforts to pool data from scattered material and put together. Links/sources embedded. However kindly point out inaccuracy/discrepancy. Little long post.

It's indeed remarkable how much we can learn from a leader. Seems about time to count number of posts that were inspired by Shri Narendra Modi ji, including this one. It was back in July'12 when I read about 63rd Van Mahotsav inauguration & my interest piqued in the long forgotten story of Mangadh hills.

Scrutinizing online/offline resources revealed many more interesting details. Here is a list of not so widely known Indian rebellions/resistance during British Raj before we talk about Mangadh/Bhil uprising.

English sources have two prime categories to group the rebellions.

1) Peasant Revolts

1.1 The Faqir and Sanyasi Rebellion (1770–1820s)

Key Details : Rose after great famine of 1770 in Bengal. Immediate cause of rebellion was restrictions imposed by the British on pilgrims visiting holy places among both Hindus and Muslims. Joint efforts by Hindu-Muslim religious groups.

Key Leaders : Bhawani Pathak, Devi Choudhurani, Maznoom Shah.

1.2 The Indigo Rebellion (1859-1862)

Key Details : Extreme profiteering by British on commercial crop Indigo. Harvesting season collided with regular food crops season. Non-violent movement.

Key Leaders : Not available. Just quote by farmer Haji Molla saying he would "rather beg than sow indigo"

Result :British government passed orders in November 1860, notifying that it was illegal to force the raiyats to cultivate indigo. (Hover ur mouse over word Indigo in blue above for info)

Indigo Cultivation in Bengal 1860's

1.3 Farazi Movement (1838-1848)

Key Details : Declared the country under British occupation to be Dar-ul-harb(Enemy territory) First ever no-tax campaign against the British Government. Armed struggle which eventually turns in to religious/anti-Hindu movement on the lines of Wahabi Movement.

Key Leaders : Shariatullah Khan and his son Muhammad Mushin (Dadu Mian)
Result : Movement died after death of Dadu Mian.

Quote from History Of Freedom Movement In India (1857-1947) by S. N. Sen

Quote from Peasant Labour and Colonial Capital: Rural Bengal Since 1770, Volume 3 by Sugata Bose on Farazi Movement.

1.4 Wahabi Movement (1830’s-1860’s)

This is sort of misfit in this list but I included to share some intriguing information.

Key Details : It's goal was to establish Muslim sovereignty/supremacy in India or a Dar-ul-Islam inspired by the Arabian Wahabi movement. This was more a religious movement, not resistance to British government. Quite interestingly British actually encouraged the movement to to enjoy fruits of the war between Sikhs and Muslims.

Key Leader : Founded by Shah Waliullah(died in 1762) and carried on Syed Ahmed Brelavi (1789-1831) belonging to Rai Baraili.

So why am I including this misfit movement here? Our Grand Old Party, Congress, proudly lists this movement in the list of India's struggle for freedom on their website.( Sure well read folks won't be surprised)

The failure of the outbreak of 1857 opened a new phase in India's struggle for freedom. The idea of open armed resistance against the British was at a discount, that it was not altogether discarded as is evident from the various rebellions which broke out in several parts of the country during the years 1859-1872. The most important of them were the Indigo Disturbances in Bengal, the movements of the Wahabis in Bihar, Bengal and other parts of the countrv and the Kukas in the Punjab.

2) Tribal Revolts

2.1 The Santhal Rebellion (1855-57)

Key Details : One of the earliest resistance to bonded labour in Bharat during British Raj. Heroic fight by tribals in Kahalgaon, Suri, Raghunathpur, and Munkatora areas of present day Jharkhand. British deploys infantry and artillery to quell the movement.(7th Native Infantry Regiment, 40th Native Infantry)

Key Leaders : Sidhu and Kanhu Murmu.
Result : Crushed brutally by cannons fire power against primitive weapons.

Charles Dickens, in English weekly Household words in the 1850s Volume 35 observed

There seems also to be a sentiment of honour among them (Santals); for it is said that they use poisoned arrows in hunting, but never against their foes. If this be the case- and we hear nothing of the poisoned arrows in the recent conflicts,-they are infinitely more respectable than our civilised enemy the Russians, who would most likely consider such forbearance as foolish, and declare that is not war

2.2 Munda Rebellion (1899-1900)

Key Details : One of the most important and prominent rebellion which took place after 1857.

Key Leader : Birsa Munda

Key Result : The Chhotanagpur Tenancy Act of 1908 provided some land ownership rights to the people and banned bonded labour of the tribal post Birsa Munda's death.

Birsa Munda

2.3 Jaintia and Garo Rebellion Rebellion (1860-1870s)

Key Details: Most widely known resistance to British from deep East India(Seven sisters states)
Key Leaders: Jaintias leader U Kiang Nongbah and Garo leader Pa Togan Sangma.

2.4 The Uprising of the Bhils (1818-1831)

Key Details : The Bhils were largely concentrated in Khandesh (present day Maharashtra & Gujarat). Khandesh came under British occupation in 1818. The Bhils considered them as outsiders. On the instigation of Trimbakji, rebel minister of Baji Rao II they revolted against the Britishers.

Key Leader : Sewaram

The Bhils revolted in 1817-19, and again in 1825, 1836 and 1846. In 1846, the Bhils under Kuwar Jiva Vasavo rebelled against the British in western India. During the 1857 Sepoy Mutiny, the Bhils rebelled under Bhagoji Naik and Kajar Singh, in Ahmednagar (now in Maharashtra). In 1858, Tatya Tope lead a rebellion in Banswara district of Rajputana. This first Bhil uprising may not have shaken the British government to the core but this is precisely where seeds of much larger and more organized resistance were sowed.

So of all these little known rebellions what motivated me to write on Bhil movement that reached its apex in Mangadh hill massacre?

1. This pertains to Gujarat's forgotten history and I was NOT taught about this during secondary/higher secondary education in Gujarat in my childhood!!
2. According to Center for Development Studies(CDS) this was the biggest sacrifice for the cause of independence anywhere in the world.
3. None of my Gujju friends had any inkling on this subject and wanted to share with them. (and my children and grandchildren)
4. Just as Shri Modiji paid his respects(and on behalf of every Indian nationalist) by dedicating a Govind Guru Smriti Van with 1507 tree plantation along with various exhibits as a tribute to these heroes, I also wanted to pay respect in my little capacity.

Guru Govind and Bhagat Movement :

Govind Gir/Guru

Guru Govind was not a Bhil, he was born a banjara (Gypsy) from Vedsa village near Dungarpur in Rajasthan in 1863. Read that again, Dungarpur, town known for other reasons (better not cited) in Gujarat today. Govind Guru was deeply moved when he saw that adivasis who traditionally owned land,forest and other resources did not have the basic necessities of life. He drew inspiration from Maharshi Dayanand Saraswati whom he met in 1881. He is also believed to be influenced by Swami Vivekananda and his Vedanta teachings. He started his reform movement among Bhils in 1892. The movement had, as its religious centerpiece, the concept of a fire God, which required his followers to raise sacred hearths in front of which Bhils pray while performing the purifying havan called dhuni. Guru Govind ji lost his wife and three children during the છપ્પનીયો દુષ્કાળ( 56th Draught?) in the year 1899-1900. This, although a personal tragedy, became turning point in his life and after this he became completely devoted to the upbringing and welfare of the Bhil community. With his persistent efforts and spiritual guidance, a section of Bhils named themselves 'Bhagat'(devotees) and stopped taking bride-price, drinking liquor, non-vegetarian food and abandoned the practice of animal sacrifice to the local deities. Bhils also began to bathe every day and sing sacred Hindu hymns. Guru also promoted live by agriculture and in peace with others, to abandon their exorcists and spirit mediums, to wear a yellow turban and rudraksh beads around their neck, and to fly a special flag over their houses.
Bhagatism depicted socio-religious renaissance. Bhil population of the states of Dungapur and Banswara in Southern Rajasthan became his followers.Guru Govind preached monotheism and moral precepts to the Bhils to convert them to mainstream Hinduism. Acceptance of the core belief in Karma, reincarnation, omnipresent and omnipotent God was one of his key message that Bhils received well.

Success of Guru's Bhagat movement had also become an eyesore for the missionaries working overtime even in those days to baptize the local community. David Hardiman (University of Warwick) notes

Perhaps the most important reason for the limited success of these missionaries was that they had in many cases been preceded by indigenous movements for social and religious reform which proved to have far greater resonance among the people. The most important of these was that of the Bhagats. These were adivasis who had developed a faith in Vaishnavite or Shaivite deities, and had reformed their lives accordingly. Commonly, they gave up meat, fish and liquor. They generally followed the bhakti path of worship, singing
bhajans which celebrated their devotion to their deities.The missionaries most affected by Govindgir’s movement were those of the Irish Presbyterian Jungle Tribes Mission.

It is important to note that this was not the only(or the first) 'Bhagat' movement. In the early 18th century, a Brahman Vaishnavite mystic called Mavji had also started such reformist movement. Another such leader, who emerged in the late nineteenth century, was called Surmal Das. He was a Bhil of Lasudia/Lusadia, which was in Idar State on the border between Gujarat and Rajasthan. In early life he had lived by robbery, but he later repented and spent thirteen years redeeming himself through hard penance, which it was believed gave him miraculous powers. He demanded that his followers give up killing animals, drinking liquor and practising witchcraft, abjure robbery and violence and live by tilling the land. He told them to worship the god Ram. Another Bhil leader Gulia (later he assumed the title of Maharaj: a saint) started similar reform campaign of religious nature. He asked them not to consume liquor or tadi. Influenced by his sermons, many of the Bhils became teetotalers. Smarting under the consequent loss of revenue from liquor sales, one of the dealers arranged to have Maharaj murdered. Another Hindu/Bhil monk named Viswanath Maharaj of Rewakantha also initiated a reformatory movement. He is said to have given the Hindu sacred thread, Janoi, to 75,000 Bhils. They all become Bhagats, i.e. devotees. They stopped drinking haro and tadi. They took vows not to eat meat, not to drink tap water and not to consume foods prepared by a non-Bhagat. These devotees would visit Maharaj’s place once a year on foot and take Prasad (sacred offerings) from him.

Coming back to Shri Govind Guru, in 1903, he set up main 'dhuni' on Mangadh Hill. It is said that on every Purnima(fool moon) day a mela(festival) was organized where he would deliver religious preaching. In 1905, Guru established village-level units of the Samph Sabha, a socio-religious organization to strengthen his Bhagat movement. Some accounts say by now the number of Bhagats in the organization had reached five lakhs. Under his leadership bhils made resolve to rise against oppressive policies of the British and forced farm labour imposed by the local princely rulers of Banswara, Santrampur, Dungarpur and Kushalgarh. Mobilized and motivated by Guru and with self-respect and self-confidence swelling, the Bhils placed a charter of 33 demands before the British by 1910 primarily relating to forced labour, high tax imposed on Bhils and harassment of the guru's followers by the British and rulers of princely states. The British, as elsewhere in other such movements across Bharat, were dismissive of such demands and refused to accept it. This is believed to be turning point when Bhagat Movement turned into rebellion. In 1913, the annual gathering of Samp-Sabha (on Magshar Punam) which was continuously held annually since establishment of main Dhuni in 1903 was approaching and Bhils had started to assemble for the same in the foothills of Mangadh two months prior to the fateful day of confrontation with British. As it is customary even today, back then the Bhils carried their traditional weapons such as spears and swords which fueled suspicion of revolt in British raks' minds. On 31st Oct,1913, guru's second-in command Punja Dhirji Parghi and his supporters attacked Gadra/Gadhran police station of the then Santrampur state near Mangadh in which an inspector Gulmohammed was killed. Rulers of princely states exploited this event to convince British that Bhils aimed to overthrow princely states and British Raj must be quelled. British forces started encircling the Mangadh Hill from three sides and neighbouring peaks under the command of British officers Major S. Bailey and Captain E. Stoiley. It is said machine guns and canons were brought loaded on donkeys and mules and positioned. British Mewar Bhil Corps and the police forces of the rulers of princely states led by three British officers surrounded Mangadh laying siege. An ultimatum was given to Bhils to vacate Mangadh hill by November 15, 1913. They refused. A final offer by the British administration via village head Dhirabhai and Nanjibhai to give Bhil farm labourers Rs.1.25 per plough per year was also rejected outright by the Bhils.

Now there is little discrepancy on the actual date of the massacre. Some sources suggests it was 13th November and others suggest 17th November(Magshar Sud Punam per Hindu calendar). Some. such as Mr. Sukhvir Singh Gehlot also suggests it was actually in 1908,7th December and not 1913.

Irrespective of the date, British committed a horrific genocide, much larger in number of casualties and cruelty. Recall reading 1507 tree plantations above? Why 1507? Because 1507 Bhils were mercilessly butchered including children,women and elderly. Virji Parghi, 86, of Khuta Tikma village, in Banswara, says his father, Soma, who survived the 1913 tragedy and died in 2000 at the age of 110, would recount to him that the British placed 'canon-like guns' on donkeys and made them swivel in circles while firing so that more people could get killed. "The relentless firing was halted by a British officer only after he saw a Bhil child trying to suckle his dead mother," says the 75-year-old from Amalia village also in Banswara district of Rajasthan. And if you believe Mr. Romesh Thapar, the total death toll was staggering 3000 lives.

Govind Guru was later captured, tried and sentenced to life imprisonment. Owing to his popularity and good conduct in jail, he was released from Hyderabad Jail in 1919 but banned from entering many of the princely states where he had a following. He settled down in Kamboi near Limbdi in Gujarat and died in 1931. Even today, his followers come to Kamboi to pay homage at the Govind Guru Samadhi Mandir. Punja Dhirji, his aide, was sentenced to life imprisonment and despatched to the Cellular Jail in the Andamans. He died years after he had served out his sentence.

Would like to conclude by saluting living legend Shri Modi ji to bring this story to mainstream and motivate me to write. It does not surprise me a tiny bit that following his announcement in July'12 to honor this forgotten Bhil community leader and true nationalist, Congress CM of Rajasthan also made a similar announcement in Nov'12. (After all Ashok Gehlot is only following a legendary leader like other millions of Indians. Can we blame him?!)


Sources :
Books : 
Culture And Integration Of Indian Tribes by Rann Singh Mann.
Hinduism, Gregorian Biblical BookShop, 1988.

Online: 

India Today Archive
http://solankimehul.wordpress.com/2011/11/22/1200-%E0%AA%97%E0%AB%81%E0%AA%9C%E0%AA%B0%E0%AA%BE%E0%AA%A4%E0%AB%80%E0%AA%93%E0%AA%A8%E0%AB%87-%E0%AA%AD%E0%AA%B0%E0%AA%96%E0%AB%80-%E0%AA%97%E0%AA%AF%E0%AB%87%E0%AA%B2%E0%AB%8B-%E0%AA%95%E0%AA%BE/ E-Book for Gujarati Readers : http://www.narendramodi.in/shri-govind-guru/ Christianity and the Adivasis of Gujarat - by David Hardiman

Tidbits on our ex-president Pratibha Patil

Entire nation stood up with awe and pride on 25th of July,2007 when Mrs. Pratibha Devisingh Patil was sworn in as the first woman president of our nation,myself included. Boasting this in lunch discussions with my non-Indian colleagues was heart-warming. I even shared pictures of her in that elegantly drapped Indian Sari(Sadi) with female colleagues. That euphoria started to wane as I started researching about her credentials and accomplishments. Until then, I had never put efforts to learn about her. The only thing I knew was that she was associated with Indian National Congress.

Here are my findings. (Links to support the claims are provided with every point below)

1) She is married to a man who is "FOUND GUILTY" BY Court of appropriating a farmer's land.

2) She is married to a man, DeviSingh Patil, prime accused in a case of abetment to suicide of Kisan Dhage, a school teacher.

3) She is sister of GN Patil,accused by Rajni Patil, widow of slained Jalgaon Congress president Vishram G Patil of hatching the murder conspiracy. She accused of shielding her brother. Interestingly Times of India actually carried this story at first and later removed. (Of course Paid media magic my friend.) Here is the old URL link on which the story was originally published. (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Pratibha_Patils_brother_killed_my_husband/articleshow/2141476.cms)

4) Unless you know/read/heard/watched how forced religious conversions of poor tribal Hindus to Christianity is a major issue having real possibilities of triggering communal disturbances and administrative challenges in many Indian states, you may not comprehend seriousness of this issue. She was the one who REFUSED to sign anti-conversion law in Rajasthan, effectively nullifying it, as mentioned in the International Religious Freedom Report 2007 by the U.S. Department of State below.

"The Governor of Rajasthan, later elevated to the Presidency, refused to sign her State's anti-conversion law, effectively nullifying it."

Read this post for more information on the subject.

5) She is the one having gone on mercy overdrive and commuted(to reduce) the death sentences of 35 petitioners to life to those who are convicted of mass murder, kidnapping, rape and killing of children -a record by any president.

Dear Mrs. Patil, better late than never, I strongly protest discrimination on behalf of Afzal Guru.

The message is that ours is banana republic. You are free to loot/arson/plunder/rape/kill/molest this massive and passive less privileged lot of humans. Criminals may start worshiping Pratibha Mataji for her unbound kindness and love. Dear criminals, I will happily provide financial support if you would like to build a temple to worship Her. Rest of the folks, watch out for more Goa type episodes.

6) She is classic case of pro-dynasty politicians with unprecedented no holds barred on spending public funds for grand-kids! YES! I am not joking. And it even gets better. Mr. Syed Akbaruddin, the spokesperson for the Ministry of External Affairs defends her citing Pakistan's President Asif Ali Zardari OR Mr. 10 percent as the world knows him. (Thank you dear Akbar for just comparison. I know we read each others tweets with utmost attention.)

7) She is the first president to complain about "smaller" living place allotted to her after stepping down. I concur, 8 rooms & 100 yards garden is not big enough.(Living in a mansion of 340 rooms for half a decade would easily spoil any mortal, why blame her!)

One may ask what is the point of such seemingly hit-job post, especially now that she has demitted from office. Well for one, it strengthens the anecdote that the more financially/morally/ethically corrupt you are, better are your chances of hierarchical advancement in nation's largest and oldest political party,Indian National Congress. (You cannot ask for a mansion larger than 340 rooms, at least not that I know of in Bharat. Vilasrao Deshmukh, Shivraj Patil many more examples available)

More importantly, we are a nation of passive/ignorant/irresponsible/callous electorate who has spectacularly failed in it's duty to keep politics clear of tainted leaders to the extent that one such leader was able to become first citizen of our Republic - AND - finish her tenure. Shame!

And believe me, the list goes on. If you are not done yet, follow the link below.
Laundry list of controversies surrounding Pratibha Patil by IBN-Live. 

With that I wait for someone to create such list for our new president, hopefully sooner than later. Yeh Indiyaah hai mere yaar. Everything is possible!

P.S.  I am a little late on my timing of this post. Ideally wanted to publish on 25th July,2012, 6 years after she became president.

Jay Hind.

Shattering the 1000 year old Myth

Video is very self-explanatory. Need not elaborate at all.And sure, you will ask for proof/evidence to back the theory in the video.Have provided links as starting point for talking heads...Please share your views. PLEASE!



Battle of Rajashtan
Bappa Rawal
Timeline of Rajasthan's History
Proof on 30,000 non-combatant civilians killed by so called 'Great Akbar'. On page 230 of book 'Advanced Study in the History of Medieval India'By Jl Mehta. Here is a link to it.

Islamic conquest of India, bloodiest in the history of World.

Most Bharatiyas(Indians) are either presented tone down/doctored version (by ruling political elite) of real history or have blissfully chose to ignore it. A history of incessant, barbaric invasions of erstwhile Bharat(India) made of small Hindu states by massive Arabic/Islamic armies amounting to unaccountable slavery,plundering and death toll for astounding 1000 years. A history in which Gujarat, Punjab and Rajasthan stood(still are) as first line of defense for larger Bharatiya subcontinent. History and Geography together explains why Hinduism has been maintained in its true traditions on Southern Bharat and declined to an extent in Northen/Western Bharat. A culture,society,land,religion that has withstood world's worst onslaught from another culture/religion is sadly unknown to most.

These videos provides an inkling why in present Bharat also it does not require a maverick or Pundit to polarize electorate with religious whipping. That being said, they are shared here for insight in to our history. There are hidden/unacknowledged fissures in our society in which millennia old animosity dwells,ferments & translates in to communal violence from time to time. As a heads up, these may not be fun watch videos,as truth never can be. Lastly, if you are interested in detailed reading, please refer to this link.